Mechanically shredding the entire HDD is the most appropriate technique for destroying magnetic platter style hard disk drives containing data with a “HIGH†security categorization. Mechanical shredding is a process that uses a powerful machine to cut, tear, or crush the HDD into small pieces, making it impossible to recover any data from the platters or the components. Mechanical shredding is the most appropriate technique for destroying HDDs with high security data, because it can:
Ensure the complete and irreversible destruction of the HDD and the data, regardless of the type, size, or condition of the HDD, and without requiring any prior preparation or disassembly of the HDD.
Provide a high level of assurance and confidence that the HDD and the data are destroyed beyond any possibility of recovery, even by advanced forensic techniques or specialized equipment.
Comply with the industry standards and the best practices for the secure disposal of HDDs and the data, such as the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Special Publication 800-88 Revision 1, Guidelines for Media Sanitization1, or the Department of Defense (DoD) 5220.22-M, National Industrial Security Program Operating Manual2.
The other options are not the most appropriate techniques for destroying HDDs with high security data. Drilling through the device and platters is a process that uses a drill to make holes in the HDD and the platters, making it difficult to read the data from the platters. Drilling through the device and platters is not the most appropriate technique for destroying HDDs with high security data, because it may not:
Destroy the entire HDD and the data, as some parts of the platters or the components may remain intact or readable, and may be recovered by sophisticated methods or tools.
Provide a sufficient level of assurance and confidence that the HDD and the data are destroyed beyond any possibility of recovery, as the number, size, and location of the holes may vary depending on the type, size, or condition of the HDD, and the skill, experience, or equipment of the operator.
Comply with the industry standards and the best practices for the secure disposal of HDDs and the data, as drilling through the device and platters is not considered a reliable or effective method of sanitization or destruction by the NIST or the DoD.
Removing the control electronics is a process that involves detaching the circuit board or the controller from the HDD, making it unable to communicate or operate with other devices. Removing the control electronics is not the most appropriate technique for destroying HDDs with high security data, because it does not:
Destroy the HDD and the data, as the platters and the components that store the data are still intact and readable, and may be recovered by replacing the control electronics or using other devices.
Provide any level of assurance and confidence that the HDD and the data are destroyed beyond any possibility of recovery, as removing the control electronics is a reversible and trivial process that does not affect the data on the platters or the components.
Comply with the industry standards and the best practices for the secure disposal of HDDs and the data, as removing the control electronics is not considered a method of sanitization or destruction by the NIST or the DoD.
HP iProcess the HDD through a degaussing device is a process that uses a powerful magnet to erase the data from the HDD by altering or eliminating the magnetic field of the platters or the components. HP iProcess the HDD through a degaussing device is not the most appropriate technique for destroying HDDs with high security data, because it may not:
Destroy the HDD and the data, as some types of HDDs, such as solid state drives (SSDs) or hybrid drives, do not use magnetic fields to store the data, and may not be affected by the degaussing device, or may require a higher level of magnetic force to erase the data.
Provide a reliable level of assurance and confidence that the HDD and the data are destroyed beyond any possibility of recovery, as the effectiveness of the degaussing device may depend on the type, size, or condition of the HDD, and the strength, duration, or orientation of the magnetic field, and it may be difficult to verify or validate the results of the degaussing process.
Comply with the industry standards and the best practices for the secure disposal of HDDs and the data, as the NIST and the DoD recommend the use of degaussing devices that are certified or approved by the National Security Agency (NSA) or the Center for Magnetic Recording Research (CMRR), and that are compatible with the type and size of the HDD.
If you want to learn more about the different techniques for destroying HDDs and the data, you can check out these resources:
How to Destroy a Hard Drive — The Family Handyman
How can I physically destroy data from a failed HDD? - Super User
The right way to destroy an old hard drive - CNET