CFA Institute ESG-Investing - Certificate in ESG Investing

The EU Taxonomy for Sustainable Activities requires that an economic activity must make a substantial contribution to at least one environmental objective (Option B), while not causing significant harm to the others. The six key objectives include:

Climate change mitigation

Climate change adaptation

Sustainable use of water and marine resources

Transition to a circular economy

Pollution prevention and control

Protection and restoration of biodiversity and ecosystems

Option A is incorrect because a company does not need to contribute to all six objectives.

Option C is incorrect because the taxonomy requires strict compliance with the “Do No Significant Harm” (DNSH) principle, meaning activities must not harm other objectives, not just outweigh harm.

References:

EU Taxonomy Regulation (2020/852)

EU Platform on Sustainable Finance Reports

European Commission: Sustainable Finance Strategy

ESG factors can impact credit risk at both issuer and industry levels by influencing financial stability, regulatory compliance, and reputational risks.

Issuer level: A company's ESG risk exposure (e.g., environmental violations, governance scandals) can lead to downgrades or higher borrowing costs.

Industry level: Sectors like coal mining, oil & gas, and tobacco face systemic ESG risks (e.g., climate regulations, social opposition).

Credit rating agencies (e.g., Moody’s, S&P, Fitch) integrate ESG risks into credit assessments.

References:

S&P Global’s ESG & Credit Ratings Framework

Moody’s ESG Risk Assessment Reports

Both Enron and WeWork faced governance failures due to excessive control and influence by their CEOs (Jeffrey Skilling for Enron, Adam Neumann for WeWork).

Why C (CEO dominance) is correct:

Enron’s CEO misled investors through fraudulent accounting practices.

WeWork’s CEO (Adam Neumann) had unchecked authority, leading to unethical corporate decisions that ultimately resulted in a failed IPO.

Why not A or B?

A (Auditor lapses) is relevant for Enron (Arthur Andersen scandal) but not a key factor in WeWork’s collapse.

B (Related-party deals) occurred at WeWork (e.g., CEO leasing buildings to his own company) but was not a central issue in Enron’s collapse.

References:

Harvard Business Review: "The Leadership Failures of WeWork and Enron"

SEC Case Studies on Corporate Governance Failures

The first formal corporate governance code was the Cadbury Report (1992) in the United Kingdom.

It established principles of good corporate governance, emphasizing board effectiveness, accountability, and audit transparency.

The U.S. Sarbanes-Oxley Act (2002) and Germany’s Corporate Governance Code (2002) came much later.

The Cadbury Report influenced global corporate governance frameworks, including OECD Principles of Corporate Governance and the G20 Corporate Governance Code.

References:

Cadbury Report (1992)

OECD Principles of Corporate Governance (2015 Update)

Scope 2 emissions refer to indirect greenhouse gas emissions resulting from the company’s consumption of purchased electricity, steam, heat, and cooling. (ESGTextBook[PallasCatFin], Chapter 3, Page 133)

For sovereign debt investors, governance factors like competition, corruption, and institutional stability are critical risks (Option C). Countries with weak institutions and high corruption levels tend to have:

Higher borrowing costs due to investor concerns about misuse of public funds.

Lower credit ratings, affecting the country's ability to issue debt at favorable rates.

Option A (Infrastructure) involves governance risks, but not at the national level like sovereign debt.

Option B (Private equity) is more influenced by corporate governance rather than national corruption levels.

References:

OECD Sovereign ESG Framework

World Bank: Corruption Perceptions Index & Sovereign Credit Risks

PRI ESG Integration in Sovereign Bonds

The ICGN Model Mandate provides guidelines for institutional investors on governance, ESG integration, and stewardship practices.

Why B (Disclose ESG risks in portfolios) is correct:

The ICGN Model Mandate states that investment managers should assess and disclose ESG risks that affect their portfolios.

This ensures transparency and helps asset owners understand risk exposures.

Why not A or C?

A is incorrect—disclosing voting activity alone does not fulfill the full engagement disclosure requirement.

C is incorrect—while long-term themes are relevant, ESG risk assessment is a more explicit requirement.

References:

ICGN Model Mandate Guidance (2023)

Global Stewardship Principles (ICGN 2022 Update)

Income inequality is a major economic issue, with the richest 10% earning significantly more than the poorest 10%.

Why C (14 times) is correct:

The OECD 2015 report found that, on average, the wealthiest 10% earn 14 times more than the bottom 10% across OECD countries.

Inequality varies by country—Nordic nations have lower disparities, while the US and UK have higher income gaps.

Why not A or B?

A (4 times) significantly underestimates the disparity.

B (9 times) is closer but still lower than the reported figure.

References:

OECD COPE Report on Income Inequality (2015)

Climate change (Option A) is a material financial risk that pension fund trustees must consider under their fiduciary duty. Failing to assess climate risks can lead to:

Legal liabilities and lawsuits from beneficiaries.

Financial losses due to stranded assets and regulatory shifts.

Option B (Choice of benchmarks) is relevant, but not the primary fiduciary risk.

Option C (Lack of ESG signals) affects engagement but does not constitute a direct legal risk.

References:

PRI: Fiduciary Duty in the 21st Century Report

UK Pensions Regulator: Climate Risk Guidance

EU IORP II Directive on ESG Integration in Pensions

Independence from previous boards is critical to ensuring that new boards can bring fresh perspectives and avoid entrenchment of outdated or ineffective policies, thus improving governance practices. (ESGTextBook[PallasCatFin], Chapter 5, Page 236)

Free allowances in an ETS are often allocated to energy-intensive companies to prevent the offshoring of emissions, also known as "carbon leakage," where companies relocate to jurisdictions with laxer environmental regulations. (ESGTextBook[PallasCatFin], Chapter 3, Page 153)

Stewardship (Option A) is a core regulatory theme in ESG investing, focusing on how investors influence corporate behavior through active ownership (voting, engagement, and dialogue). Regulatory frameworks such as the UK Stewardship Code, Japan Stewardship Code, and EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) emphasize investor stewardship responsibilities.

Scenario analysis (Option B) is used for risk assessment, particularly in climate stress testing (e.g., TCFD recommendations), but is not the primary focus of ESG regulations.

Green bond issuance (Option C) is regulated under ICMA Green Bond Principles and EU Green Bond Standards, but ESG investing regulations are broader than just bond issuance.

References:

UK Stewardship Code 2020

EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR)

Japan FSA: Principles for Responsible Institutional Investors

The EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) (Option B) requires financial firms to disclose how their investment products integrate ESG factors.

Article 8 ("light green") funds promote ESG factors.

Article 9 ("dark green") funds have sustainability as their objective.

Option A (EU Taxonomy Regulation) defines sustainable activities but does not regulate investment disclosures.

Option C (EU CSRD) applies to corporate ESG reporting, not investment products.

References:

EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) 2019/2088

European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) SFDR Guidelines

PRI Guide to ESG Fund Classification

Companies integrating ESG into operations enhance efficiency through improved resource management, governance, and stakeholder engagement.

Why A (Efficiency) is correct:

ESG initiatives lead to cost savings, innovation, and better risk management.

Example: Energy-efficient supply chains reduce waste and increase productivity.

Why not B or C?

B (State intervention) is incorrect—proactive ESG efforts often reduce regulatory risks.

C (Negative externalities) is incorrect—effective ESG integration minimizes externalities, not increases them.

References:

McKinsey: ESG and Business Efficiency Study (2023)

A fund that excludes the worst ESG performers relative to their peers is using both negative and norms-based screening.

Why C (both negative and norms-based) is correct:

Negative screening removes poor ESG performers outright.

Norms-based screening excludes companies that violate international ESG standards (e.g., UN Global Compact).

Why not A or B?

A (Negative screening only) is incomplete—norms-based screening also plays a role.

B (Norms-based only) is incorrect—some exclusions go beyond norms (e.g., fossil fuel bans).

References:

PRI: ESG Screening Strategies (2023)

UN PRI’s Guide to Norms-Based Screening