CFA Institute ESG-Investing - Certificate in ESG Investing

Brown divestmentrefers topublicly traded firms selling off polluting assets (e.g., coal mines, oil refineries) to third partiesrather than shutting them down.

Screening out fossil fuels (A) is part of exclusionary ESG investing but does not define brown divestment.

Investing only in positive-impact firms (B) is more aligned with green or impact investing.

References:

Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI) ESG Divestment Strategies

CFA Institute Guide to Carbon-Intensive Asset Divestment

MSCI Research on Brown-to-Green Transition Strategies

========

Tipping elementsareEarth system components (e.g., ice sheets, rainforests, ocean currents) that can undergo irreversible changeswhen pushed past a critical threshold.

Planetary boundaries (B)set safe limits for human environmental impacts.

Environmental externalities (C)are economic costs imposed on society.

References:

Stockholm Resilience Centre Tipping Points Report

IPCC Climate Change Tipping Elements Analysis

UNFCCC Climate Risk Framework

========

Quantitative ESG analysisinvolvesmeasurable, numerical data.Issuer-reported carbon emissionsareobjective, standardized, and widely used incarbon footprintingandclimate risk modeling.

Executive compensation policies (B)andESG commitments (C)arequalitativefactors.

References:

MSCI ESG Quantitative Metrics Guide

CFA Institute ESG Data Standardization Report

Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI) ESG Data Challenges

========

Light Greenbonds supportshort-term emissions reductionsbut do not contribute significantly tolong-term climate resilience.

Medium Green (C) supports more sustainable, long-term transitions.

Yellow (A) is not a recognized CICERO category.

References:

CICERO Shades of Green Bond Ratings

Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI) Green Bond Evaluation Framework

Climate Bonds Initiative Green Bond Certification Guide

========

When searching for an asset manager with an ESG approach, it is essential for an institutional asset owner to understand whether the asset manager's strategy aligns with their sustainability objectives. The most appropriate question to ask in the RFP is whether the asset manager aims for positive, measurable ESG outcomes beyond financial returns. This question assesses thecommitment to achieving concrete ESG results, which is a critical factor in evaluating the manager's integration of ESG factors into their investment process. Detailed questions about portfolio holdings or which broad market index the manager tracks are less relevant to assessing the ESG integration​​.

The Cadbury Commission proposed that every public company should have an audit committee meeting at least twice a year.

Step-by-Step Explanation:

Background of the Cadbury Commission:

The Cadbury Commission, established in the UK in 1991, aimed to address issues of corporate governance in the wake of several high-profile corporate scandals.

According to the CFA Institute, the commission's recommendations have had a lasting impact on corporate governance practices globally.

Key Recommendations:

One of the key recommendations of the Cadbury Commission was that every public company should establish an audit committee composed of independent non-executive directors. This committee should meet at least twice a year to review the company’s financial reporting and internal controls.

The CFA Institute highlights that this recommendation was intended to enhance the oversight and accountability of financial reporting processes, reducing the risk of financial misstatements and fraud.

Importance of Audit Committees:

Audit committees play a critical role in ensuring the integrity of a company's financial statements. They provide an independent review of the financial reporting process, internal controls, and the external audit process.

The MSCI ESG Ratings Methodology emphasizes the importance of robust audit committee practices in maintaining investor confidence and protecting shareholder value.

Implementation and Global Influence:

The recommendations of the Cadbury Commission have been widely adopted and incorporated into corporate governance codes around the world. The requirement for regular audit committee meetings has become a standard practice in many jurisdictions.

The CFA Institute notes that effective audit committees are a cornerstone of good corporate governance, helping to ensure transparency, accountability, and the accuracy of financial reporting.

References:

CFA Institute, "Environmental, Social, and Governance Issues in Investing: A Guide for Investment Professionals."

Historical documents and reports on the Cadbury Commission’s recommendations and their impact on corporate governance.

The Sustainalytics database is primarily used for company ESG assessment. Here’s a detailed explanation:

Company ESG Assessment:

Sustainalytics provides detailed ESG ratings and research for individual companies. Their assessments cover various ESG risks and opportunities that companies face, and these ratings are used by investors to evaluate the ESG performance of companies.

The database includes ESG Risk Ratings that measure the degree to which a company’s economic value is at risk due to ESG factors. These ratings help investors integrate ESG considerations into their investment processes​​​​.

CFA ESG Investing References:

The CFA Institute’s ESG curriculum highlights the role of Sustainalytics in providing comprehensive ESG assessments of companies. These assessments are crucial for investors looking to incorporate ESG factors into their investment decisions​​​​.

Prevalence in the US:

Shareholder resolutions are a prominent feature of the corporate governance landscape in the United States. They allow shareholders to propose changes or raise concerns about a company's policies, practices, and governance.

According to the CFA Institute, the US has a well-established tradition of shareholder activism, with a significant number of resolutions submitted annually on various issues, including ESG matters.

Regulatory Framework:

The regulatory framework in the US, particularly the rules enforced by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), provides shareholders with the right to propose resolutions and ensures that these proposals are included in the company’s proxy materials if they meet certain criteria.

The CFA Institute notes that the US regulatory environment is conducive to shareholder activism, facilitating the submission and consideration of shareholder resolutions.

Engagement and Influence:

Shareholder resolutions are an important engagement tool for investors in the US, allowing them to influence corporate behavior and advocate for changes in policies related to environmental, social, and governance issues.

The MSCI ESG Ratings Methodology highlights that shareholder resolutions can drive significant changes in company practices, particularly when they garner substantial support from investors.

Comparison with Other Countries:

While shareholder resolutions are also used in other countries such as the UK and Australia, the frequency and impact of these resolutions are more pronounced in the US.

The CFA Institute indicates that the shareholder resolution process in the US is more formalized and widely used compared to other jurisdictions, making it the most common country for the proposal of shareholder resolutions.

References:

CFA Institute, "Environmental, Social, and Governance Issues in Investing: A Guide for Investment Professionals."

MSCI ESG Ratings Methodology, which discusses the role of shareholder resolutions in corporate governance.

A bottom-up ESG engagement approach involves direct interaction with specific investee companies to address ESG issues. Initiating dialogue with an investee company's investor relations team is an example of this approach.

Direct Communication: Engaging directly with the investor relations team allows asset managers to discuss specific ESG issues relevant to the company. This direct line of communication can lead to more detailed and company-specific insights.

Targeted Engagement: This method focuses on individual companies, enabling asset managers to address specific concerns and influence company practices more effectively. It allows for a deeper understanding of how ESG issues are managed at the company level.

Active Ownership: By engaging with companies, asset managers exercise active ownership, encouraging companies to adopt better ESG practices. This can lead to improved ESG performance and, ultimately, better long-term investment returns.

References:

MSCI ESG Ratings Methodology (2022) - Highlights the importance of direct engagement with companies as part of an effective ESG strategy​​.

ESG-Ratings-Methodology-Exec-Summary (2022) - Discusses various engagement approaches and emphasizes the value of direct dialogue with investee companies in improving ESG practices​​.

The Principles for Sustainable Insurance (PSI) were established by the United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative (UNEP FI). Here’s a detailed explanation:

UNEP FI and PSI: The United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative (UNEP FI) launched the Principles for Sustainable Insurance in 2012. The PSI aims to promote sustainability within the insurance industry by encouraging insurers to integrate environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors into their business strategies and operations.

Objectives of PSI: The PSI provides a global framework for the insurance industry to address ESG risks and opportunities. It helps insurers improve risk management and decision-making processes, enhance their reputation, and contribute to sustainable development.

Not the Other Options:

Climate Disclosure Standards Board (CDSB): The CDSB is an international consortium of business and environmental NGOs. It was not established by UNEP FI but aims to provide a framework for companies to report environmental information with the same rigor as financial information.

Global Sustainable Investment Alliance (GSIA): The GSIA is a collaboration of the world's largest sustainable investment membership organizations. It was also not established by UNEP FI but works to deepen the impact and visibility of sustainable investment organizations.

CFA ESG Investing References:

According to the CFA Institute, the PSI was developed by UNEP FI to promote the integration of ESG factors in the insurance industry, enhancing the industry's role in sustainable development (CFA Institute, 2020).

The PSI is highlighted as a key initiative under UNEP FI to advance sustainable insurance practices globally​​​​.

=================

The EU’s Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) mandates that companies need to meet at least two of the following three criteria to fall under its scope of mandatory compliance:

EUR 40 million in net turnover

EUR 20 million in assets

250 or more employees

This requirement is designed to ensure that significant entities are subject to sustainability reporting, reflecting their potential impact on and responsibility towards environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors.

References:

The CSRD directive outlines the scope and criteria for mandatory sustainability reporting within the EU.

According to a study of the Hermes UK Focus Fund, engagement objectives most likely to be achieved through shareholder activism include restructuring and financial policies. The study found that the success rate for achieving objectives related to restructuring and financial policies was higher compared to other objectives such as remuneration policy changes and improvements to investor relations. This indicates that shareholder activism is more effective in driving changes in corporate structure and financial strategies​​​​.

The role of auditors is to assess the financial reports prepared by management and to provide assurance that the reports fairly represent the performance and position of the business. Auditors do not guarantee that the numbers are correct or that there is no fraud; rather, they provide an opinion on the overall fairness and accuracy of the financial statements.

Audit Opinion: Auditors provide an independent opinion on whether the financial statements are presented fairly, in all material respects, in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework.

Reasonable Assurance: Auditors aim to obtain reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error. This involves evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies and the reasonableness of significant estimates made by management.

Stakeholder Confidence: By providing assurance on the fairness of financial reports, auditors enhance the confidence of stakeholders, including investors, creditors, and regulators, in the financial information provided by the company.

References:

MSCI ESG Ratings Methodology (2022) - Discusses the role of auditors in providing assurance on financial statements and enhancing stakeholder trust​​.

ESG-Ratings-Methodology-Exec-Summary (2022) - Highlights the importance of auditors in ensuring the fair representation of a company's financial performance and position​​.

The UK’s Green Finance Strategy identifies the policy lever of financing green as directing private sector financial flows to economic activities that support an environmentally sustainable and resilient growth.

Encouraging Private Investment: The strategy aims to mobilize private sector investment into green projects and technologies that contribute to environmental sustainability and climate resilience.

Supporting Green Growth: By directing financial flows towards sustainable economic activities, the strategy supports the transition to a low-carbon economy and promotes long-term economic growth that is resilient to environmental and climate risks.

Policy Framework: The strategy outlines a framework for aligning financial flows with sustainability goals, including setting standards, enhancing disclosures, and providing incentives for green investments.

References:

MSCI ESG Ratings Methodology (2022) - Discusses the role of financial flows in promoting sustainable growth and the importance of directing investments towards green activities​​.

ESG-Ratings-Methodology-Exec-Summary (2022) - Highlights the objectives of the UK’s Green Finance Strategy in supporting environmentally sustainable economic growth​​.