CIMA F3 - Financial Strategy

In CIMA F3, finance leases are analysed as a form of debt financing and are compared directly with bank loans when evaluating long-term funding options. The syllabus (under Financing Decisions and Leasing vs Buying) explains that a finance lease is economically similar to borrowing to purchase an asset, because the lessee assumes substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership.

Option B is correct because one key advantage of a finance lease over a bank loan is that the lessor retains legal ownership of the asset, which provides strong security for the lender. As a result, the lessor’s risk is lower than that of a bank providing an unsecured or partially secured loan. CIMA F3 study guidance highlights that this reduced risk can allow the lessor to offer more favourable interest rates or financing terms than a conventional bank loan.

The other options are incorrect under current accounting and financial strategy principles:

A is incorrect because finance leases are not off-balance sheet. Under IFRS 16 (examined in F3), finance leases must be recognised on the statement of financial position, increasing both assets and liabilities and therefore affecting gearing.

C is incorrect because tax depreciation (capital allowances) normally remain with the legal owner, the lessor. These benefits are not “passed on” directly, although they may be reflected indirectly in lease pricing.

D is incorrect because maintenance is a feature of operating leases, not finance leases. In a finance lease, the lessee is responsible for maintenance and insurance.

A – Integrated reporting is designed to improve the quality of information for providers of financial capital.

B – A core aim is to show the interdependencies between the different capitals (financial, manufactured, human, social, natural, intellectual).

E – It explicitly aims to support integrated decision-making and value creation over the short, medium and long term.

C is wrong (it usually increases work), and D is wrong (focus is long-term, not short-term).

A – Seek a White Knight alternative bidder.

B – Appeal to shareholders, emphasising strong growth prospects and the undesirability of break-up.

D – Inform shareholders about the higher underlying value of assets (including intangibles) to demonstrate undervaluation.

(Competition authorities focus on competition, not redundancies, and giving rights to buy bonds is not a standard or effective takeover defence.)

CIMA F3 clearly states that acquisitions enhance shareholder wealth only if they create real economic value, not just strategic or reputational benefits.

A. Press coverage – ✘

Media exposure does not directly generate cash flows or economic value.

B. New opportunities for employees – ✘

While beneficial socially, this does not directly enhance shareholder wealth unless it improves profitability.

C. Cultural diversity – ✘

CIMA F3 treats this as a soft benefit with no guaranteed financial return.

D. Acquiring Intellectual Property – ✔

IP can generate monopoly power, licensing income, and sustainable competitive advantage, directly increasing future cash flows.

E. Exploiting production synergies – ✔

Cost savings and operational efficiencies are a primary source of acquisition value highlighted throughout the F3 syllabus.

F. Elimination of competition – ✔

Reduced competition can increase pricing power and market share, improving long-term profitability and shareholder value.

Z can borrow:

Floating: L + 1

Fixed: 10%

Compare with each:

A: L + 1.5 (worse floating), 9.5 (better fixed) → symmetric, no clear comparative advantage.

D: L + 1.5 (worse), 10.5 (also worse) → Z better in both, no deal.

C: L + 1.5 (worse floating), 9% (much better fixed) → C has advantage in fixed, Z has in floating → good swap partner.

E: L + 1.5 (worse), 12 (much worse) → Z better in both.

Answer: C. Company C

 A – True. A special dividend can create expectations of similar future payouts, while a buyback is more clearly one-off.

 B – True. A repurchase can be interpreted by some investors as management having no positive-NPV projects, i.e. a possible negative signal about growth opportunities.

 C – False. The repurchase price is not automatically the open-market price; it may involve negotiation or a premium/discount.

 D – True. In many tax regimes, capital gains (from buybacks) are taxed more favourably than dividend income, so some shareholders may prefer repurchases.

 E – False. Even if approved, individual shareholders are usually free to choose whether or not to tender their shares.