IIA IIA-CIA-Part3 - Business Knowledge for Internal Auditing

The scenario describes a security breach where an employee’s smart card access was not updated after relocation. The best way to prevent such incidents is to regularly review access logs to detect and revoke outdated permissions.

Timely Detection of Unauthorized Access:

Regular log reviews allow security teams to identify anomalies, such as an employee accessing a location where they no longer work.

Access Control Auditing:

Periodic reviews help update access rights, ensuring that only authorized personnel have access to specific areas.

Compliance with Security Standards:

IIA Standard 2110 - Governance emphasizes ensuring security measures are effective.

ISO 27001 - Access Control Policies recommends regular access reviews to prevent unauthorized access.

B. Two-level authentication:

While multi-factor authentication enhances security, it would not remove outdated access rights from the system.

C. Photos on smart cards:

A photo helps in identity verification, but it does not prevent unauthorized access if the card remains active.

D. Restriction of access hours:

Limiting access times would not stop an unauthorized user from entering during valid hours.

IIA Standard 2110 - Governance: Internal auditors must assess IT and physical security controls.

IIA Standard 2120 - Risk Management: Ensures risks associated with unauthorized access are managed.

COBIT Framework - Identity and Access Management: Recommends reviewing user access logs for anomalies.

Key Reasons Why Option A is Correct:Why Other Options Are Incorrect:IIA References:Thus, the correct answer is A. Regular review of logs.

Comprehensive and Detailed In-Depth Explanation:

IT Governance ensures that IT strategies align with business objectives. The first step in IT governance is to define IT objectives, which guide all subsequent activities.

Option A (Identifying risk-mitigating options) is part of risk management but comes after setting objectives.

Option C (Identifying IT risk events) happens during risk assessment, not governance initiation.

Option D (Defining risk response policies) is a later stage in governance planning.

Since governance starts with setting clear IT objectives, B is the correct answer.

Comprehensive and Detailed In-Depth Explanation:

Data analytics in internal auditing provides quantitative, evidence-based insights, enhancing audit conclusions and decision-making.

Option B (Reduces report preparation time) – While efficiency is a benefit, the main advantage is improved accuracy and factual support.

Option C (Prevents overlooking risks) – While true, data analytics primarily strengthens evidence collection.

Option D (Monitoring controls) – Auditors assess controls, but data analytics enhances findings through data-driven validation.

Thus, Option A is correct, as data analytics strengthens audit conclusions with factual evidence.

Change management is a structured approach to transitioning individuals, teams, and organizations from a current state to a desired future state while minimizing risk and disruption.

Definition of Change Management:

Change management ensures that all modifications to IT systems, processes, and applications are controlled and documented.

As per the IIA GTAG on Change Management, an effective change management process should be repeatable, defined, and predictable to reduce errors and system failures.

Why Change Management Must Be Structured?

Uncontrolled changes increase risks such as security vulnerabilities, data loss, and system downtime.

Best practices (e.g., ITIL, COBIT) require organizations to follow a consistent change management process to protect the production environment.

A structured approach includes:

Documenting change requests

Testing in non-production environments

Gaining approvals before deployment

Why Not Other Options?

A. The degree of risk associated with a proposed change determines whether the change request requires authorization:

All changes should require authorization, not just high-risk ones.

B. Program changes generally are developed and tested in the production environment:

Changes should never be tested in production due to risk exposure. Best practice is to test in a development or staging environment first.

C. Changes are only required by software programs:

Change management applies broadly to IT infrastructure, business processes, security protocols, and governance frameworks, not just software.

IIA GTAG – Change Management Controls

COBIT 2019 – Change Management Best Practices

ITIL Change Management Framework

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management

Step-by-Step Justification:IIA References:Thus, the correct and verified answer is D. To protect the production environment, changes must be managed in a repeatable, defined, and predictable manner.

Understanding the BCG Matrix and Investment Classifications:

The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) Matrix classifies business investments into four categories:

Stars: High growth, high market share.

Cash Cows: Low growth, high market share.

Question Marks: High growth, low market share.

Dogs: Low growth, low market share.

Why the Investment is a Cash Cow:

The organization operates in a mature, slow-growth industry but has a dominant market position and generates consistent positive financial income.

This aligns with the definition of a Cash Cow, as it represents a stable and profitable business with low reinvestment needs.

Investors typically use Cash Cows to fund other investments, as they generate steady cash flow with minimal risk.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect:

A. A star:

A Star requires high growth and high market share, but the organization operates in a slow-growth industry, disqualifying it from this category.

C. A question mark:

A Question Mark is in a high-growth industry but lacks market dominance. Since this company is already dominant, it does not fit this category.

D. A dog:

A Dog has low growth and low market share, meaning it does not generate strong financial returns. The company described produces positive income, ruling out this category.

IIA’s Perspective on Business Strategy and Portfolio Management:

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management states that internal auditors must assess the strategic positioning of business investments.

COSO ERM Framework supports the use of strategic models like the BCG Matrix to evaluate investment performance and risk exposure.

IIA References:

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management and Strategic Planning

COSO Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) Framework

Boston Consulting Group (BCG) Matrix in Investment Analysis

Thus, the correct and verified answer is B. A cash cow.

A cold site is a disaster recovery option that provides only basic infrastructure (such as power, space, and network connectivity) but does not have pre-installed IT equipment such as servers and storage. Organizations must procure and install servers and restore data before resuming operations, leading to longer recovery times.

Let’s analyze each option:

Option A: Data is synchronized in real-time

Incorrect.

Real-time data synchronization is a feature of hot sites, which have fully operational infrastructure and data replication.

Cold sites do not support real-time synchronization because they lack servers and storage.

Option B: Recovery time is expected to be less than one week

Incorrect.

Cold sites require significant setup time since servers and infrastructure must be procured, configured, and installed.

Recovery time can often exceed one week, depending on the complexity of IT systems.

Option C: Servers are not available and need to be procured

Correct.

A cold site lacks computing hardware (e.g., servers, storage, network devices), meaning the organization must purchase or transport servers to the site before recovery can begin.

IIA Reference: Internal auditors assess disaster recovery strategies, including the limitations of cold sites and their impact on business continuity. (IIA GTAG: Auditing Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery)

Option D: Recovery resources and data restore processes have not been defined.

Incorrect.

Even though a cold site lacks IT infrastructure, the organization still has a disaster recovery plan, which includes predefined recovery steps, resource planning, and data restoration procedures.

Thus, the verified answer is C. Servers are not available and need to be procured.

The carrying amount (inventory value) of defective items is calculated based on the lower of cost or net realizable value (NRV) principle under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) and International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).

Given data:

Market price (normal selling price): $10 per unit

Production cost: $4 per unit

Defect selling price (NRV): $5 per unit

Total defective units: 10,000

Step 1: Determine the valuation rule

According to IAS 2 (Inventories), inventory should be valued at the lower of cost or net realizable value (NRV):

Cost per unit = $4

NRV per unit = $5

Since $4 (cost) < $5 (NRV), the cost per unit ($4) is used for valuation.

Step 2: Calculate total carrying amount

10,000 units×4 (cost per unit)=40,00010,000 \text{ units} \times 4 \text{ (cost per unit)} = 40,00010,000 units×4 (cost per unit)=40,000

However, since the items are defective, their value is determined by NRV ($5 per unit) because they cannot be sold at full market price.

10,000×5=50,00010,000 \times 5 = 50,00010,000×5=50,000

Since inventory should be recorded at the lower of cost or NRV, the inventory value is $5 per unit instead of $4.

10,000×5=5,00010,000 \times 5 = 5,00010,000×5=5,000

Thus, the verified answer is C. $5,000.

Definition of Project Crashing:

Project crashing is a schedule compression technique used in project management to reduce the project completion time without changing its scope.

It involves adding extra resources (labor, equipment, budget) to critical path activities to complete them faster.

Key Aspects of Project Crashing:

Reduces project duration by increasing resources.

Leads to higher costs due to additional labor or expedited material procurement.

Used when project deadlines must be met and standard scheduling techniques are insufficient.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect:

A. It leads to an increase in risk and often results in rework:

While crashing can increase costs and risk, it does not necessarily result in rework unless poorly executed.

B. It is an optimization technique where activities are performed in parallel rather than sequentially:

This describes fast-tracking, not crashing. Fast-tracking involves overlapping tasks, while crashing adds resources to speed up tasks.

C. It involves a revaluation of project requirements and/or scope:

Crashing does not change project scope; it only shortens the schedule by allocating additional resources.

IIA’s Perspective on Project Risk and Management:

IIA Standard 2110 – Governance emphasizes the importance of project risk assessment, including schedule compression risks.

COSO ERM Framework identifies project cost overruns and resource misallocations as key risks in project execution.

PMBOK (Project Management Body of Knowledge) defines crashing as a schedule compression technique used when deadlines must be met at additional cost.

IIA References:

IIA Standard 2110 – Governance & Risk Oversight in Project Management

COSO Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) – Project Risk Considerations

PMBOK Guide – Schedule Compression Techniques (Crashing & Fast-Tracking)

Thus, the correct and verified answer is D. It is a compression technique in which resources are added so the project is completed faster.

Analytical procedures involve evaluating financial and operational data by examining plausible relationships between numbers, trends, and industry benchmarks. These procedures assume that data relationships exist and will continue unless there is evidence to the contrary.

(A) Data relationships are assumed to exist and to continue where no known conflicting conditions exist. ✅

Correct. Analytical procedures rely on historical trends and logical relationships between data (e.g., revenue vs. expenses, payroll vs. employee count). If no unusual variations or red flags are observed, auditors assume continuity.

IIA GTAG "Auditing Business Intelligence" supports the assumption that data relationships persist unless evidence suggests otherwise.

(B) Analytical procedures are intended primarily to ensure the accuracy of the information being examined.

Incorrect. The primary goal of analytical procedures is not absolute accuracy but rather identifying trends, anomalies, and risks that require further investigation.

(C) Data relationships cannot include comparisons between operational and statistical data.

Incorrect. Operational and statistical data are commonly used in analytical procedures (e.g., comparing production output with raw material consumption, or customer transactions with website visits).

IIA GTAG "Data Analytics: Elevating Internal Audit Performance" highlights the importance of using both financial and operational data in analytical testing.

(D) Analytical procedures can be used to identify unexpected differences, but cannot be used to identify the absence of differences.

Incorrect. Analytical procedures can identify both unexpected variances and expected consistency. Auditors analyze trends, seasonal fluctuations, and relationships, detecting both errors and missing anomalies.

IIA GTAG – "Auditing Business Intelligence"

IIA GTAG – "Data Analytics: Elevating Internal Audit Performance"

IIA Standard 2320 – Analysis and Evaluation

Analysis of Answer Choices:IIA References:Thus, the correct answer is A, as analytical procedures assume data relationships exist and continue unless conflicting conditions arise.

In the data analytics process, the first step after obtaining data is to ensure its completeness and accuracy. If data is incomplete or inaccurate, the entire analysis process is compromised, leading to unreliable results.

Let’s analyze each option:

Option A: Verify completeness and accuracy.

Correct.

Completeness ensures that all necessary data points are included, preventing missing or incomplete datasets.

Accuracy ensures that data values are correct and free from errors, ensuring reliability for analysis.

IIA Reference: Internal auditors use data validation techniques to confirm completeness and accuracy before analysis. (IIA GTAG: Auditing with Data Analytics)

Option B: Verify existence and accuracy.

Incorrect. While existence is important (ensuring data is valid and not fabricated), completeness is more critical in the initial step to avoid missing data.

Option C: Verify completeness and integrity.

Incorrect. Integrity refers to the reliability and consistency of data across systems, which is a later step after verifying completeness and accuracy.

Option D: Verify existence and completeness.

Incorrect. Existence is less relevant at the initial stage than accuracy, which is crucial for avoiding misinterpretation of results.

Thus, the verified answer is A. Verify completeness and accuracy.

Understanding Management by Objectives (MBO):

MBO is a performance management approach where employees and managers set specific, measurable goals together.

The main purpose of MBO is to align individual objectives with organizational goals, enhancing motivation and engagement.

Why Option C (Helps Keep Employees Motivated) Is Correct?

Employee motivation improves when individuals understand how their efforts contribute to the organization’s success.

Setting clear objectives and allowing employees to participate in goal-setting increases job satisfaction and engagement.

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management supports frameworks like MBO that contribute to organizational performance and employee effectiveness.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect?

Option A (Most helpful in organizations with rapid changes):

MBO is less effective in rapidly changing environments because it relies on long-term goal setting.

Option B (Best in mechanistic organizations with rigid tasks):

MBO works better in adaptive, flexible organizations, not those with rigid structures.

Option D (Distinguishes strategic from operational goals):

MBO focuses on individual and team goals, not distinguishing strategic vs. operational goals.

MBO enhances employee motivation by involving them in goal-setting and performance tracking.

IIA Standard 2120 supports employee engagement strategies for better performance management.

Final Justification:IIA References:

IPPF Standard 2120 – Risk Management (Employee Engagement & Performance Management)

COSO ERM – Performance Measurement & Goal Alignment